The AIVX AI Visibility Index.
We asked 5 AI search engines the same 30 questions real customers ask, from “best personal injury lawyer in Phoenix” to “best DSCR loan lenders”, and recorded every business they recommended and every source they cited.
The short version: AI engines rarely agree on who to recommend. Being visible in one says little about the others, and each one leans on different kinds of sources. A business that wants to be recommended has to show up in the places each engine actually reads.
1. The engines mostly disagree
Across the 30 questions, the engines recommended 463 distinct businesses. 68% of them were named by only one engine. Only 16 were named by all 5, and for 12 of the 30 questions at least one business made every engine’s list. The two Google products agreed most often; the least similar pair was Gemini and Perplexity.
| Engine pair | Average overlap |
|---|---|
| Google AI Overviews + Google AI Mode | 43% |
| ChatGPT + Google AI Mode | 35% |
| ChatGPT + Google AI Overviews | 30% |
| ChatGPT + Gemini | 22% |
| ChatGPT + Perplexity | 21% |
| Gemini + Google AI Mode | 20% |
| Perplexity + Google AI Overviews | 19% |
| Perplexity + Google AI Mode | 18% |
| Gemini + Google AI Overviews | 16% |
| Gemini + Perplexity | 16% |
Overlap is the share of businesses two engines have in common for the same question (named by both ÷ named by either), averaged over the questions both answered.
2. Each engine reads different sources
Perplexity showed the most sources, 8.0 per answer, while Gemini showed 1.1 and often none at all. Most citations point to businesses’ own websites, but ChatGPT leaned heavily on directories and rankings, and Google AI Overviews was the engine most likely to cite Reddit and YouTube.
The directories cited most often were Super Lawyers, Expertise.com, ContractorsRanked, Clutch, EnergySage, Doyle’s Guide, Best Lawyers and Houzeo. If your industry has a directory like these, your listing there is part of your AI visibility.
| Engine | Businesses per answer | Sources per answer | Answers with any source |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 5.4 | 3.4 | 100% |
| Gemini | 7.2 | 1.1 | 37% |
| Perplexity | 4.2 | 8.0 | 100% |
| Google AI Overviews | 5.5 | 6.0 | 85% |
| Google AI Mode | 5.7 | 3.7 | 32% |
3. Who every engine agreed on
When every engine names the same business, that business is visible across the whole AI landscape for that question. These are the businesses every engine named. Google’s two products covered the first 20 questions, so the real estate and B2B rows compare the other three engines.
| Industry | Question | Named by every engine |
|---|---|---|
| Law firms | best personal injury lawyer in Phoenix | Lamber Goodnow Injury Lawyers, Kelly Law Team |
| Law firms | top estate planning attorneys in Dallas | No business named by every engine |
| Law firms | who is the best divorce lawyer in Seattle | David Starks – McKinley Irvin |
| Law firms | best employment lawyer in Chicago for wrongful termination | HKM Employment Attorneys LLP |
| Law firms | which law firm should I call after a truck accident in Atlanta | Fried Goldberg LLC |
| Financial services | best fee-only financial advisor in San Diego for retirees | Pure Financial Advisors, LLC |
| Financial services | best hard money lenders for fix and flip loans | Kiavi, RCN Capital |
| Financial services | best DSCR loan lenders for real estate investors | Kiavi, Visio Lending |
| Financial services | best business checking account for a small business | Bluevine |
| Financial services | best mortgage broker in Sacramento | No business named by every engine |
| Home services | best roofing company in Houston | Amstill Roofing |
| Home services | best HVAC repair company in Phoenix | No business named by every engine |
| Home services | who are the best plumbers in Charlotte | Charlotte Plumbing |
| Home services | best kitchen remodeling contractor in Austin | No business named by every engine |
| Home services | best solar installer in Las Vegas | No business named by every engine |
| Healthcare | best dermatologist in Miami | No business named by every engine |
| Healthcare | best orthopedic surgeon for knee replacement in Nashville | Southern Joint Replacement Institute |
| Healthcare | best dentist for dental implants in Scottsdale | No business named by every engine |
| Healthcare | best physical therapy clinic in Portland Oregon | Whole Body Health Physical Therapy, Rose City Physical Therapy - Portland |
| Healthcare | best fertility clinic in Los Angeles | No business named by every engine |
| Real estate | best real estate agent in Seattle to sell my house | No business named by every engine |
| Real estate | best property management company in Tampa | No business named by every engine |
| Real estate | which we buy houses companies in Atlanta are legit | Maximum Cash Home Buyers (3 engines) |
| Real estate | best commercial real estate brokerage in Chicago | CBRE, JLL, Cushman & Wakefield (3 engines) |
| Real estate | best home builder in Boise | No business named by every engine |
| B2B and marketing | best AI visibility optimization agency | NoGood, Omniscient Digital, iPullRank, Siege Media (3 engines) |
| B2B and marketing | best generative engine optimization agency | iPullRank (3 engines) |
| B2B and marketing | best SEO agency for law firms | Rankings.io (3 engines) |
| B2B and marketing | best managed IT services provider in Dallas | No business named by every engine |
| B2B and marketing | best CPA firm for small businesses in Seattle | No business named by every engine |
4. AI personalizes, and it can flatter you
We first ran ChatGPT signed in to an account with memory turned on. That account belongs to our founder, who also runs a lending brokerage and a marketing agency. In 5 of 30 answers, ChatGPT worked those businesses into its recommendations, and for “best AI visibility optimization agency” it suggested AIVX as one to evaluate. We discarded that run and re-ran ChatGPT in a temporary chat with personalization off; none of those answers mention our companies. Google’s answers also used the searcher’s location, adding Seattle-area lenders to national lending questions.
The lesson: checking your own AI visibility from your own account will overstate it. Test signed out, in a private or temporary chat, or from a clean account.
5. AI still gets facts wrong
For “best dermatologist in Miami”, Gemini recommended a practice tied to a doctor who died in 2015. Engines also cited ranking sites that rank their own publishers first, which Perplexity itself flagged in its B2B answers. Outdated or self-serving sources flow straight into AI answers, which is why accurate, current information about your business on your own site and on the directories AI reads matters.
What to do with this
- Check every engine, not one. With 68% of recommendations unique to a single engine, ranking in ChatGPT tells you little about Gemini or Google.
- Make your own site citable. Businesses’ own websites were the most-cited source type overall. Clear service pages, locations, credentials and structured data give engines something to quote.
- Claim the directories your industry’s answers cite. Legal answers leaned on Super Lawyers and Best Lawyers; home services on Expertise.com and contractor rankings; B2B on Clutch.
- Earn real mentions on Reddit and YouTube. Google AI Overviews cited them more than any other engine.
- Test without personalization. Your own account will flatter you.
Want to know where your business stands on each engine? That is exactly what an AI Visibility Audit™ measures.
Methodology
Engines: ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews, Google AI Mode. Microsoft Copilot was excluded from this round because it required a human verification check before answering.
Coverage: ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity answered all 30 questions. Google AI Overviews and AI Mode cover the first 20 (law, financial services, home services and healthcare); Google began blocking our automated queries as “unusual traffic” partway through, and we chose not to work around it. Round 2 will run Google more slowly.
When and how: each question was asked once per engine on November 15–16, 2026, exactly as written below, in a fresh chat. ChatGPT ran in a temporary chat with personalization off. Gemini, Perplexity (free plan) and Google ran signed in to the same account from the Seattle area, so Google results reflect that location. Google AI Overviews were read from a standard Google search; AI Mode from Google’s AI Mode tab.
What we counted: every business an answer recommended or listed as an option, in order, and every source label shown with the answer. Hidden sources behind “+N” counters are included in the per-answer source counts but not in the source-type breakdown. Source types were assigned by hand. Business names were matched across engines after removing suffixes such as “LLC” and “Law Firm”.
Limits: AI answers vary from one run to the next and by person and place, so treat these as a snapshot, not a ranking. We will repeat the same questions each month and publish the changes.
The 30 questions
- best personal injury lawyer in Phoenix (Law firms)
- top estate planning attorneys in Dallas (Law firms)
- who is the best divorce lawyer in Seattle (Law firms)
- best employment lawyer in Chicago for wrongful termination (Law firms)
- which law firm should I call after a truck accident in Atlanta (Law firms)
- best fee-only financial advisor in San Diego for retirees (Financial services)
- best hard money lenders for fix and flip loans (Financial services)
- best DSCR loan lenders for real estate investors (Financial services)
- best business checking account for a small business (Financial services)
- best mortgage broker in Sacramento (Financial services)
- best roofing company in Houston (Home services)
- best HVAC repair company in Phoenix (Home services)
- who are the best plumbers in Charlotte (Home services)
- best kitchen remodeling contractor in Austin (Home services)
- best solar installer in Las Vegas (Home services)
- best dermatologist in Miami (Healthcare)
- best orthopedic surgeon for knee replacement in Nashville (Healthcare)
- best dentist for dental implants in Scottsdale (Healthcare)
- best physical therapy clinic in Portland Oregon (Healthcare)
- best fertility clinic in Los Angeles (Healthcare)
- best real estate agent in Seattle to sell my house (Real estate)
- best property management company in Tampa (Real estate)
- which we buy houses companies in Atlanta are legit (Real estate)
- best commercial real estate brokerage in Chicago (Real estate)
- best home builder in Boise (Real estate)
- best AI visibility optimization agency (B2B and marketing)
- best generative engine optimization agency (B2B and marketing)
- best SEO agency for law firms (B2B and marketing)
- best managed IT services provider in Dallas (B2B and marketing)
- best CPA firm for small businesses in Seattle (B2B and marketing)
Download the full data (CSV): one row per business recommendation, with engine, question and position.
Disclosure: AIVX sells AI visibility services. AIVX did not appear in any of the answers counted here, including the two questions about AI visibility agencies.
Where does your business show up?
An AI Visibility Audit runs your customers’ questions across every major AI engine and shows exactly who gets recommended instead of you.
Start with the free, automated Snapshot. Then get a hands-on Review & Proposal from AIVX. Clients get the full AI Visibility Audit™: real testing of what ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews say about you and your competitors.